Compare the leading national and certified-installer roofing networks on price, warranty, materials and install timeline.
GAF Master Elite contractors deliver the strongest combination of certified installer training and a lifetime Golden Pledge warranty in 2026. Owens Corning Platinum Preferred is a close second with similar manufacturer backing. Erie Home leads on metal roofing, Power Home Remodeling on shingle replacement at scale, and Long Roofing on East-Coast service quality.
Side-by-side overview of every pro we reviewed.
| Pro | Rating | Best For | Starting Price | Warranty | Materials | Install Time |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
#1GAF Master Elite | 9.4/10 | Top certification | From $4.50/sq ft | Up to 50 yr Golden Pledge | Asphalt shingles | 1–2 days |
Owens Corning Platinum | 9.2/10 | Premium shingles | From $4.80/sq ft | Lifetime (Platinum) | Asphalt shingles | 1–2 days |
Erie Home | 8.9/10 | Metal roofing | From $9.00/sq ft | 50 yr non-prorated | Stone-coated steel | 2–4 days |
Power Home Remodeling | 8.7/10 | Scale & service | From $5.20/sq ft | Double lifetime | Asphalt shingles | 1–2 days |
Long Roofing | 8.4/10 | East coast service | From $5.50/sq ft | Lifetime | Architectural shingles | 1 day |
Source: QuackQuack editorial · Data verified April 2026
Answers to the questions homeowners ask most before getting quotes.
Our editors apply a single methodology to every category so you can compare apples to apples.
Years in business, accreditations (BBB, NARI, manufacturer-certified), and independent customer reviews.
Quality of materials, installer training, length and transferability of labor and product warranties.
Quoted price ranges, in-house financing terms, and how transparent the company is about costs.
Answer a few quick questions and get matched with up to 4 vetted local roofing pros - free, no obligation.
Get my a free quote✓ No obligation • ✓ 100% free • ✓ Vetted pros only
More side-by-side reviews in Roofing & Exterior.
